Analysts' Comments on Responses to the Welsh Government Consultation (2004) on the draft Technical Advice Note 8

Return to menu page
Whilst all the responses were exaned and classified the analysts chose to comment on some responses. The comments are listed below. You may see the original response by clicking on the file name in the extreme right hand column after noting the identification number of the submission. This will download a file of approximately 100 responses which will contain the response you have selected. Some of the files are quite large and will take a while to download. Save the downloaded (pdf) file somewhere on your computer so that you can refer to it without further downloading should you wish to examine any further responses contained in the file.

Entries are in reverse alphabetical order of the responder's name

Use your browser's usual 'Find' facility if you wish to search for a phrase on this page.
Responder CategoryResponder ViewResponder NameAnalyser's Comments ResponderID
File Name
LocalGovernment NeutralTendingForTan8 Ynys Mon county Council 'Overall the contents of the draft ministerial intreim policy statemen.... deserve to be supported.' To view look up responderID 1573 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Wynford Jones * To view look up responderID 479 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Wrexham County Borough * To view look up responderID 1141 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyEnergy NeutralTan8 Western Power distribution Points out some of the distribution difficulties that need addressing To view look up responderID 360 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 West Wales Eco Centre, Newpoer, Pembs Asks for small groups of turbines, particularly local or community owned objectives. Example of spin off from a farmer's project in Pembrokeshire. To view look up responderID 1588 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 West Coast Energy * To view look up responderID 1471 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Welsh Local Government Association 'Would like to see a balance approach to renewables and would not support a blinkered rush to wind' Useful document interpreted as being against Tan 8 as it stands. To view look up responderID L54 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Welsh Consumer Council * To view look up responderID 1101 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed Welsh Assembly Government Business and Environment * To view look up responderID 135 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
TourismEnterprise AgainstTan8 Wales Tourist Board There wiillbe significant implications for tourism businesses given the cumulative impact. Three SSAs are included in parts of our Tourism Growth Area. Impact of tourism should be a material considera To view look up responderID 997 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTendingForTan8 Wales Coastal and Maritime Partnership (WCMP) Suggests that Tan 8 does not recognise large potential of offshore energy production. To view look up responderID 594 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Wales Biomass Centre, Cardiff University. Chiefly to do with section on biomass but is supportive of wind section of Tan 8. I believe the author (Dr. F. Slater) a well known ecologist in Mid Wales. To view look up responderID 438 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Wakefield Has requested audited annual output vs forecast information but has been unable to get it To view look up responderID 287 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 Vicar of Llanybydder and Llanwenog with Llanllwni * To view look up responderID 1552 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Vale of Glamorgan Council. comments on electricity transmission - should be underground. Planning for wind farms - resource implications pointed out. To view look up responderID 400 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Usk Civic Society Says that policy will not reduce green house gases, higher energy prices and there will be a gradual insidious and comprehensive sacrifice of tracts of countryside. To view look up responderID 575 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8 United Utilities No specific quidance on wind farms below 25MW threshold which are acceptable outside the strategic search areas To view look up responderID 1432 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
LocalGovernment ForTan8 Torfaen County Borough Council * To view look up responderID 1344 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Ton & Sarah Roberts * To view look up responderID 638 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 The Wildland Group Particularly against the Nant y Moch SSA which would devastate the characteristics of remoteness and man made structures. Request it be removed To view look up responderID 1073 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 The Gower Society Says that proposals don not seriously address a long term solution to global warming but are aimed at a quick fix resolution so short t erm self imposed political problem. To view look up responderID 706 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTan8 The Countryside Agency, West Midlands Region Suggests that, in carrying out the more detailed mapping and landscape assesment work envisaged, Powys County Council consult with the relevant English local authorities To view look up responderID 914 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 The Carbon Trust in Wales Detailed comments without an identifiable conclusion To view look up responderID L24 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
Individual ForTan8 TF @ L S Joynson Mainly supporting the development of turbines at Brechfa. Looks at it from the farming point of view To view look up responderID 1572 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Tegni Ltd., Corwen * To view look up responderID 1599 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingForTan8 Sustrans response says little or nothing about TAN 8 directly but seems to favour large scale renewable enerty developments To view look up responderID 1626 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy NeutralTan8 Sunwarm International Solar energy company wishing for solar energy tobe included in Tan8 To view look up responderID 1597 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyEnergy NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Sundance Sundance is a not for profit workers cooperative for the development of renewable energy. Draws attention to other renewable energ sources. To view look up responderID 637 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 SP (Scottish Power) Transmission and Distribution Deals with ability of the transmission network to require further investment. Challenge of obtaining planning consent should not be underestimated - a major risk to achieving targets To view look up responderID 1347 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 SOCME (Mynydd-y-Gwair) A detailed document. Also questions whether the Welsh Assembly Government has fulfilled its obligations under the Arhus Convention on participation To view look up responderID 1346 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Snowdonia National Park Society Tan 8 does not take enough cognisance of effect on National Park of wind turbines external to it. EG the Society objected to the Hiraethog proposals To view look up responderID 927 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Snowdonia National Park Some of areas are close to and visible from the National Park. Draft TAN 8 does not explicitly recognise the value of landscapes. LANDMAPO not used despite heavy investment by CCW and LPAs in develop To view look up responderID 1623 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Shawater Ltd, Bath This company is primarily concered with hydro and tidal power production. Is therefore rather critical of the emphasis on wind - could have been classifed as "neutral tending for TAN8", but I gave th To view look up responderID 8 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 ScottishPower Comprehensive view of how to proceed. Keys to success - include established wind and forestry expertise. Forests alone can provide up to 930MW To view look up responderID 1375 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Ryland Llewellyn (Caerphilly Council) Emphasises importance of other energy contributors ie.biofuels To view look up responderID 596 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 RWE npower A major integrated electricity generating company. Believes that more positive policy towards run-of--river hydro electric is appropriate To view look up responderID 1459 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Rural Land Services, Burford, Oxfordshire Advises land owners on alternative sources of income throughout the UK To view look up responderID 718 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 RSPB Cymru RSPB is g enerally supportive but stress need to ensure that normal planning criteria apply To view look up responderID 1600 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Royal Town Planniong Institute Says Tan8 is a clear planning stategy for the whole of Wales To view look up responderID 1621 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingForTan8 Rosie Carmichael Asks that comments be taken account of but these comments appear to conflict with Tan 8 proposals making the response, in effecr, not in favour of TAn8 To view look up responderID 1616 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed Rosemarie Illes This is an internal WAG email which says that Planning were advising the Minister not to stay for Q&A To view look up responderID 924 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 RICS Wales Includes a paper on impact of wind farms on the value of residential property To view look up responderID L58 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Richard & Hilary Hayes Nicely voiced objection. Sad and relevant story about Radnage Church pre norman records being sent for salvage in second world war To view look up responderID 587 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
LocalGovernment ForTan8 Rhondda Cynon Taff Council response to Tan8 * To view look up responderID 1384 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
Individual ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Rev Pam Cram Has concerns about local impact but is generally in favour To view look up responderID 327 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment AgainstTan8 Resolven Community Council * To view look up responderID 657 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Renewable Energy Power Associatin long document, seems to suggest that 'Criteria based' developmetns should be allowed outside the search areas To view look up responderID 1632 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Renewable Energy Partnership (REP) # VERY pro wind farm development, both in and outside SSAs. But does pinpoint areas that objectors may use ie. grazing common land and commoners' rights. To view look up responderID 484 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 RDC Developments wind farms looking for wind speeds of at least 7.5m/s but higher turbines wikk offset lower assumption. To view look up responderID 1470 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Ramblers Association (Wales) A reasoned case concluding with, amongs other things, "the landscape of rural Wales is a priceless economic and spiritual asset which should not be marred except for urgent and explicit reasons" To view look up responderID 1308 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 Radnorshire Wildlife Trust * To view look up responderID 1276 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8 R.E.Phillips & Partners Firm acts for a number of site owners and developers. Methodology is flawed and should have been subject to public consultation. Ommission of common land misrepresents many real opportunities. To view look up responderID 1467 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 R Slater THis letter complains particularly about the consultation process -'a case study in how a consultation should not be handled. Interpreted as being against at least one TAn 8 ' To view look up responderID 248 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 R John Howard In favour of a general policy but not does not lke the details which are listed in detail with critisims To view look up responderID 736 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Public meeing in Pontarddulais * To view look up responderID 1181 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment AgainstTan8 POWYS COUNTY COUNCIL #An important document. Includes concern that Tan 8 has been undertaken in isolation from planning authorities with most experience of wind energy developments. Clear lack of landscape assessment. Req To view look up responderID 552 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Pontarddulais Action Committee Against Wind Turbin * To view look up responderID 576 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Planning Officrs Society for Wales Says that the designation of SSA's would normally be crried out through a formal development process with its opportunities for scrutiny and challenge at a public enquiry. What process will there for To view look up responderID 925 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Planning Officer Denbighshire County Council Discussion of cross authority implications of the draft To view look up responderID 1370 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
PoliticalParty ForTan8 Plaid Cymru - The Party of Wales. Plaid Cymru suipports Tan8 but believe it is too restrictive. To view look up responderID 1382 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Petition from Neath 26 signatories To view look up responderID 592 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Petition from Mari Hobbs Wording of petition not visible To view look up responderID 205 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Petition from Blenau, Carmarthenshire 16 signatories To view look up responderID 593 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 People Against Corwen/Cerrigydrudion Turbines (PAC Detailed document from PACT dealing with Gerrig y drudion mostly, but also against tan8 in its entirety To view look up responderID 217 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
TourismEnterprise AgainstOne+Tan8 Pentir Pumlumon NantyMoch area only objected to To view look up responderID 307 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingForTan8 Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority Quibbling over details but happy to support since National Parks are exempt To view look up responderID 680 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyOther NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Pembrokeshire Bio Energy Ltd. Argues case for biomass rather than wind To view look up responderID 1409 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Organic Farmer, Ynysmeudwy, Swansea Valley # should perhaps fall into a 'buisiness other' categoroy' To view look up responderID 917 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Open Spaces Society somewhat difficult to classify, Kate Ashbrook writes to say that the Society Fully Supports the submission of the Council for National Parks To view look up responderID 1015 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Open Spaces Society Largely a case for defense of Common Land. To view look up responderID 566 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8WithSiteExceptions ntl broadcasting need opportunity to work further with WAG to advice on development affects on broadcasting and mitigation measures and costs. To view look up responderID 1378 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Npower renewables Not generally in favour of strategic search area approach but pragmatically accept. Areas designated unlikely to yield 800 mw of new capacity by 2010 Common land eminently suitable. historic landscape To view look up responderID 1468 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
OtherGovOrg ForTan8 North West REgional Assembly #an English Assembly To view look up responderID 1570 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 North Wales Ramblers Association Says that Tan8 is a major document which will have far reaching effects on Wales and the people of Wles. Proposals will cause serious damage to Wales and the rewards will be mere tokens. To view look up responderID 1322 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 North Wales Energy Group Detailed analysis disputing the facts. To view look up responderID 747 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 North Radnorshire and South Montgomeryshire wind f * To view look up responderID 908 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstTan8 Nick Bourne, Welsh Conservative Group, WAG. The siting of wind farms in areas of national beauty is indicative of the problem of large scale wind farms. Much more balanced approach is required To view look up responderID 586 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstTan8 Neath Port Talbot Labour Party no public airing of or debate on the issues. Neat and Port Talbot authority has already done much to address the dimension of power generation To view look up responderID 1367 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
LocalGovernment AgainstTan8 Neath Port Talbot Council Planning Dpt Need for genuine public debate. Political expediency in delivering 2010 targets is being favoured notwithstanding the long term visual effects. Closeness of areas ot National Park bondaries, within 1 To view look up responderID 636 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Neath and Port Talbot Councillor Alun Llewe A considered response. Comes to the view that Tan8 is inadequate and that its policy basis is flawed. To view look up responderID 1226 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 National Trust Wales * To view look up responderID 1081 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 National Grid Transco #Critical of Tan 8's lack of consideration of transmission. Says that the improvement of the transmissions system has not been addressed, it needs to b e given the same positive planning as renewabl To view look up responderID 533 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 National Farmers' Union Additional points made include the need for other forms of renewable energy (including crops), and also the "coarse grained nature" of the mapping process (so did the final version of TAN8 differ from To view look up responderID 9 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 N T Bale Wals Tourist Board pre TAN8 policy statement is attached which states that commercial wind turbines are inappropriate unless proposals have no adverse impact on landscape To view look up responderID 781 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Mynydd Llansadwrn Action Group A detailed response to the MIPPS and Tan 8 To view look up responderID 1022 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Mynnydd y Gwynt Ltd. #Argues that SSA area D (Pumlumon) should have its boundary refined to include their proposed farm which is close to it To view look up responderID 485 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 Mrs S Davies Lives in an area directly affected. Asks for extension of consultation proocess and better plans/maps To view look up responderID 222 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Mr F Morgan INcludes a response from WAG To view look up responderID 380 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyOther AgainstTan8 Mount Severn Activity Centre * To view look up responderID 346 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Mid Wales Energy Agency Aberystwyth Mission is to reduce carbon emissions across mid Wales through the promotion of renewable energy and energy efficient technologies. To view look up responderID 1207 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Mick Green * To view look up responderID 608 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 Michael Romeling Objections centre on area A Denbigh Moors but says that same will apply in other areas To view look up responderID 216 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstTan8 Mark Isherwood AM North Wales (Conservative) Contributions from man y constituents have led to the conclusion that TAN8 is environmentally and economically unsustainable. To view look up responderID 1208 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Mark Isherwood AM Concludes in his paper that TAN8 is environmentally and economically unsutainable To view look up responderID 1627 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstOne+Tan8 Margam Labour Party Interesting response covering a range of issues including the fact that the area with a low carbon gas generating station and proposed biomass station is already contributing. To view look up responderID 1305 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstOne+Tan8 Llanfihangel Rhos y Corn/Brechfa Community Associa major marketing activities at Brechfa by Carmarthenshire C.C, branding the Towy and Cothi valleys as peaceful.GB Horse Endurance rides affected. No access for construction without major road developm To view look up responderID 1247 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstOne+Tan8 Llandybie Community Council Lack of Consultation To view look up responderID 1534 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstTan8 LlanbadarnFynydd, Llandrindod Councillor .... the Welsh Assembly ........... is committed to destroying the Welsh Landscape To view look up responderID 1420 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 leeds Welsh Society * To view look up responderID 1034 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 L R Mytton Extensive argument based on general energy issues. Also comments in flaws in tan8 document and consultation process To view look up responderID 318 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Kay Little and Peggy Lilford A detailed response To view look up responderID 532 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed Kay Little Comprehensive paper on the damage caused by wind development infrastructure. Not classified owing to it being supplementary to a previous response. To view look up responderID 1021 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed Kay Little Not analysed as it is an addendum to a previous response To view look up responderID 1065 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual NotAnalysed Julian Kelbrick Has laready sent a previous letter of objection ; this letter requests clarification of particular points To view look up responderID 218 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 John Muir Trust * To view look up responderID 1596 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 John Etherington Useful response covering many points. An independent cost benefit analysis of wind power is required. Draft is an engineering target not a carbon reduction target. To view look up responderID 1086 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual NeutralTan8 Jim Pool, visiting Prof. Cardiff Uni. Visiting Prof. in Engineering Dept. Cardiff Uni. (and Environment Agency ). Deals with tidal impoundment scheme for N. Wales. To view look up responderID 529 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Jack Harris Consultancy Strongly objects to outstanding natural beauty of Wales being destroyed................. by completely unnecessary wind farms To view look up responderID 1548 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8 J. W. Greaves and sons litd, llechwedd Slate Mines The company appear to support onshore wind farms wheter they do not cause demonstrable harm to the environment To view look up responderID 1182 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Ioan Richard Same author as 523 To view look up responderID 522 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed Ioan Richard same author as 522 To view look up responderID 523 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTan8 Instiitute of Grassland and Environmental Research Comments on wood fuel section which is over emphasised compared with dedicated energy crops. The author is head of biomass research at the Institute. To view look up responderID 1100 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Inland Water Ways Association * To view look up responderID 600 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Includes Roger Williams MP letter Many complaints from constituents about lack of notice. Much fuller public consultation needs to take place. To view look up responderID L52 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Ian Rogers This is the same individual and the same letter as consultee 258 To view look up responderID 250 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual NeutralTan8 Ian Hurst This letter complains about the consultation process To view look up responderID 234 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Howard Evans, Director, Mynydd y Gwynt Wishes the Pumlumon\nant y moch SSA extended to include the Mynydd y Gwynt area. To view look up responderID 1288 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 House Builders Federation (HBF) Comments largely to do with energy efficiency in homes. No mention of wind turbines. To view look up responderID 562 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
TourismEnterprise AgainstOne+Tan8 Hiraethog Countryside Holidays The tourism industry wil be non-existent once the landscape is spoiled. The long term employment from the wind farm will in no way compensate for the loss of jobs in tourism To view look up responderID 1014 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Head of Planningg Services, Carmarthenshire County There is an implied acceptance of the policy and he concentrates on suggestions for improvement of defects in it To view look up responderID 721 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstTan8 H Francis MP Views Tan 8 with Concern To view look up responderID 639 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Gwynedd County Council # justification for figure of 4 TWH is fundamental to the guidance. This should form part of an appendix. No definite statement to show that it supports Tan8 many questions asked. To view look up responderID 1185 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Gwynedd Archaeological Trust "Overall we have to say we were disappointed by both documents, particularly some of the presumptions that underlie them" To view look up responderID L3 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstTan8 Gwenda Thomas AM for Neath Must be open debate on renewable energy. All inputs from the public to my office have been opposed to Tan8 Little appreciation of the combined visual and sonar effects of heavy concentration of turbin To view look up responderID 1372 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Greenpeace * To view look up responderID 1602 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy NeutralTan8 Green Land Reclamation Ltd Original interest of the company was with energy from "green land" - landfill gas from waste disposal sites, but has worked on a range of technologies. Also interested in externalities. Says nothing To view look up responderID 2 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Goronwy A. Williams An extensive analysis It also makes special mention of Nantymoch and of Owain Glyndwr's battle. To view look up responderID 155 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstOne+Tan8 Glyncorrwg Ward LAbour Party Specifically their own area. Also criticises the timing of the consultation process. Many copies of the letter and note.Response from WAG included To view look up responderID 306 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Glyncorrwg Action Group * To view look up responderID 323 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 Glyncorrwg action group Area suffered from mining, its natural beauty has now been rehabilitated and the responder feels this should not be reversed. To view look up responderID 370 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingForTan8 Glamorgan/Gwent archaeological trust This is a response regarding historical landscapes To view look up responderID 311 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual ForTan8 Gareth Tucker Objects to EIAs being needed for installations with hub heights of greater than 15m. Wants more freedom for developers. To view look up responderID 688 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Gamesa Energy UK One of the largest wind farm developers in the world. Wishes to record its full support for the positive in Tan8 To view look up responderID 1379 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Friends of the Earth Supportive of Tan 8. Amongst its recommendations says that the Nant y moch SSA should be deleted and offered to MOD as substitute for the Camddwr area To view look up responderID 1619 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Forward Planning Officer Pembrokeshire * To view look up responderID 1209 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
OtherGovOrg ForTan8 Forestry Commission Wind farm opportunities for Private Woodlands too. Forestry.... a positive siting factor. Says wind farms less intrusive in forestry areas. To view look up responderID 1641 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Force 9 Energy Ltd. Critical of Tan 8 designating SSAs - should be less restrictive in planning. To view look up responderID 434 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment ForTan8 Flintshire County Council Preliminary response, not ratified by County Council To view look up responderID 150 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Flintshire County Council just sugesting improvements To view look up responderID 715 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 EON (formerly Powergen) draft Tan 8 is detached from the practicalities that dictate the feasibility of wind development. needs further mapping analysis, no provision for cumulative impact To view look up responderID 1603 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
OtherGovOrg ForTan8 Environment Agency Wales * To view look up responderID L1 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Energy Saving Trust * To view look up responderID 1472 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Energy Beyond Oil Gives interesting statistics on the German experience To view look up responderID 1078 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 EMP Consultants Consultants in sustainable energy. Includes the criticism that the extra grid capacity in Mid Wales and North Wales is proposed without plans. To view look up responderID 863 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Elan Valley Trust Says it is clear that landscape will suffer and will be damaged beyond repair. Cumulative effect will affect the Elan valley estate. The future of the Trust's rural area is now under threat. To view look up responderID 610 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Edmund Hayward * To view look up responderID 1549 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 EcoGen Available grid connection will prove a b arrier. Must be sympathetic to projects outside the search area. Much of the Forestry Commission land will have to be used. SSAs are not a feasible area for m To view look up responderID 1466 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Ecodyfi (Andy Rowland) * To view look up responderID 409 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Eco 2 A detailed critique of Tan 8 but essentially for it. Asks for a reinstatement of a South East Wales SSA which was understood to be included until very late in th e internal consultation. To view look up responderID 864 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed EArth Cymru Network #Appear to be against Tan 8 but is more of a hand out than anything. Mot analysed To view look up responderID 1079 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8 Eaga Partnership Ltd "An emloyee owned Social Entreprise working for Central Government, Welsh Assembly Governemnt"etc. Involved in energy efficiency and demand side management. To view look up responderID 1463 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstOne+Tan8 Dyffryn Clydach Community Council near Neath Disappointed that Welsh Assembly Government has not chosen to consult Community Councils directly on this matter. To view look up responderID L61 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 dulas ltd Machynlleth and Albro Planning and Envir Comprehensive response Nant y moch area doubtful on hydrological, ecological and road access grounds and is very close to the nationally acclaimed Plynlymon range. To view look up responderID 1464 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Dr Hywel Francis M.P. Encloses a Neath - Port talbot Unitary Authority documen opposng in principle the draft Tan8 To view look up responderID 1639 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingForTan8 Design Commission for Wales * To view look up responderID L59 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstOne+Tan8 Derwen Community Council No direct consultation with Community Council. Vast majority of residents do not want the turbines. Important issues such as this should be properly consulted with public bodies ... in future To view look up responderID 358 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Denbighshire County Council long document worth a read - 'broadly supports' Tan 8 then says 'flawed in a few significant areas' To view look up responderID 920 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Denbighshire Against Rural Turbines Mentions the apparent illogicality of omitting from the t arget the two proposed off shore proposals.. Growing body of opinion that wind energy is flawed. To view look up responderID 896 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 Denbighshire Against Rural Turbines * To view look up responderID 7 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 David Bellamy Author/artist Severe criticism of the consultation process and request for it to be done again professionally To view look up responderID 226 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstTan8 Cynghor Tref Pontardawe * To view look up responderID 928 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 Cynghor Cymuned Mawr Insufficient publicity accorded to the draft To view look up responderID 1033 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstOne+Tan8 Cynghor Cymuned Llanfihangel Rahos-y-corn Commonsense needs to be exercised prior to continuing with such drastic measures s are at present to be considered. To view look up responderID 1592 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstTan8 Cynghor Cymuned Cilybebyll A policy of concentration: just recovering from ravages of industry; little publicity; lack of recognition of town and community councils in the consultation. To view look up responderID 1195 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Cymru Solar WElcomes Tan* and its support for solar technologes To view look up responderID 1620 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 CVAG (Ceiriog Valley Action Group) Concern that CCW LANDMAP has not been used. Short sighted acceptance that renewable altlernative nergy provision equates to on shore wind power, fails to take account of impact on landscape and socio To view look up responderID 1345 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTan8 Crown Estate Deals with offshore developments not onshore Tan 8 matters To view look up responderID 1091 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
CompanyOther NeutralTan8 Crown Castle UK Ltd & ntl - run radio and TV trans Have experience with 3500 annual planning applications. Well known that wind farms can adversely affect terrestrial tv, Keen to minimise disruption. To view look up responderID 1453 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 Craigcefnparc Primary School, Swansea * To view look up responderID 1319 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 CPRW supplementary Includes a report on a CCW commissioned study of applying the LANDMAP methodology and data to the Neath/Portalbot, Bridgend, Rhondda Cynon Taf/Caerphilly strategic search areas To view look up responderID 1440 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 CPRW Carmarthen Branch "Anarchy in the Hills" Considers the alternatives. To view look up responderID 1020 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 CPRW Not against wind but believes its development should only occur where environmental impact is significantly and demonstrably outweighed by the energy benefits it achieves. To view look up responderID 671 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 County Councillor Ioan M Richard, City and County * To view look up responderID 916 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
CompanyOther AgainstOne+Tan8 Countryside Solutions, Devizes Consider re-allocation of current Strategic Search Areas or increasing their number To view look up responderID 816 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
OtherGovOrg ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Countryside Council for Wales # CCW not previously inmvolved. How arbitrary was the process in selecting SSAs. Many comments on Tan8. Cumulative impact could result in total change in SSA landscapes To view look up responderID 1593 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Country Landowners Association Broadly welcome TAN 8. members wish to see new and renewable energyu projects as part of a newly invigorated local economy. To view look up responderID 1087 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Country Guardian Tan 8 appears to be designed to ... proliferateonshore wind turbines in Wales. In doing so it ignores the operational evidence available from Denmark and Germany. To view look up responderID 1439 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Council for the National Parks CNP concerned at proximity of Area D to the southern boundary of the park and other areas too To view look up responderID L51 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Council for British Archaeology Tan 8 approach is welcomed but there is a need for detailed, open and robust analysis before the boundaries of any SSA area is confirmed. To view look up responderID 1569 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Conway Valley Civic Society * To view look up responderID 349 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment ForTan8 Conway county borough council Council accepts the strategic approach, regrets there was not wider consultation on the renewable energy targets set by WAG, serious concern about more wind farms elsewhere in the Borough,regrets lac To view look up responderID 1343 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Community of Llanfynnydd Against Wind Power Statio * To view look up responderID 1075 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Community Councillor, Ammanford * To view look up responderID 1531 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstTan8 Coed Ffranc Community Council objects that WAG are putting into the draft a policy driven land use policy without any meaningful publci consultation and examingation eg through Development Plan Process To view look up responderID 1629 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstTan8 Clydach Community Council * To view look up responderID 685 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Clwydian Range AONB Worried by suggestion that "small scale" turbine projects may be considered in an AONB. Established regional groups eg North Wales Planning Forum were not consulted. To view look up responderID 689 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
PoliticalParty AgainstTan8 Clwyd South Conservative Association * To view look up responderID 1137 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Clwyd Powys Archaeological Trust Asks for adjustmejnt in Strategic Search Area A To view look up responderID 1391 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstOne+Tan8 CLOUT - Conway Locals Opposing Unnecessary Turbine An argued case To view look up responderID 1259 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Clive Myhill A farmer's viewpoint To view look up responderID 1595 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Clipper Windpower Inc Wind project developer and manufacturer of wind turbines To view look up responderID 815 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment AgainstTan8 City and County of Swansea Opposed to over reliance on wind. Views from North Swansea and Gower AONB affected. Local democracy eroded. Succinct reply for a local authority. To view look up responderID 1445 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual ForTan8 Christine Chapman AM Essentially for TAN8 but that sensitivity is needed in the level of devilopment appreved. Communities need to be involved. To view look up responderID 1625 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8 Cetws Common Holdings Ltd. S concerned that they might be excluded from developing a wind farm To view look up responderID 1515 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
OtherGovOrg ForTan8 Ceredigion Eenrgy Forum An organisation formed in 2004 to coordinate sustainable energy initiatives in Ceredigion, resposne covers a range of technologies To view look up responderID 1624 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
LocalGovernment ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Ceredigion County Council There are areas of Ceredigion more appropriate to developments os the scale envisaged for the search ar ea. No discussions with local authorities To view look up responderID 926 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Centre for Alternative Technology Machynlleth CAT offer congratulations for TAN 8, but thinks more SSAs should be included e.g. MOD land and more of Dyfi Valley Biosphere. To view look up responderID 687 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Cefn Croes Action Group Recommends a visit to Cefn Croes in development as an indication of the devastation caused by turbine development To view look up responderID 1640 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Carolyn Smethhurst Wales has 50 % of UK turbines with 5 % of population (at time of writing in 2004) To view look up responderID 686 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyOther ForTan8 Carmarthenshire Energy Agency Welcomses the encouragement of microgeneration. Community benefits should be a requirement of all wind farm developments. To view look up responderID 1435 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTendingForTan8 Cardiff County Council Planning officer * To view look up responderID 1383 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Camddwr Community Trust (Tregaron area) Critical of Tan 8 in that it ignores their wind turbine project because it is in a Tactical Training Area. To view look up responderID 528 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Cambria Archaeology (Dyfed Archaeological Trust) * To view look up responderID 898 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTan8 Cadw Propose that south western corner of strategic area F at Glyncorrwg is excluded To view look up responderID 1458 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 British Wind Energy Association Long response wanting Tan 8 to go further.# Gives reasons for Nant y Mhor (sic) being impractical for large scale wind development. To view look up responderID 1473 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTan8 British Waterways * To view look up responderID 1516 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 British Hydropower Association (BHA) Comments mainly on hydro power element of Tan 8 but accepts that wind energy is an important part of the mix. To view look up responderID 531 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
TourismEnterprise AgainstTan8 British Holiday and Home Parks Association (BH&HPA Wales Tourist Board investigation showed 11% of walkers would stee clear of a wind farm, 51% agreed that wind farms spoil the look of the Welsh Countryside To view look up responderID 414 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTan8 Bridgend & Caerphilly CBCs * To view look up responderID 1431 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
LocalGovernment NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 Brecon Beacons National Park Approach to renewables needs to be balanced, the draft places a heavy reliance on wind To view look up responderID 1633 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 Brecknock Wildlife Tust Gives Welsh Wildlife Trusts point of view. Draws atention to Brechfa Forest SSA as breeding habit of the protected Nightjar. To view look up responderID 1077 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
TourismEnterprise AgainstTan8 Brandy HOuse Frm, Felindre, Knighton * To view look up responderID 1521 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
CommunityCouncil AgainstTan8 Blaenhonddan Community Council Also questions why Community Councils were not on the official Consultation List as it is their duty to represent members of the public on this issue. To view look up responderID 1315 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Bheara Ltd Thinks may be problems in forestry SSA's To view look up responderID 598 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTan8 BBC Essential that developers are made aware that wind turbines can disrupt television reception To view look up responderID 1614 in file:
1600-1654.pdf(8 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 Batia Tucker * To view look up responderID 782 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 B.A.Jukes, Environmental Consutant An argued case To view look up responderID 1547 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 B. & M. Lynn A good local letter with a quote from Carwyn Jones on the value of tourism when he was WAG Minister for the Environment To view look up responderID 547 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NonGovOrg ForTan8 Awel Aman Tawe Endorses comments by Carmarthen Energy Agency and would like the strategic area to cover the whole of Cefn Gwrhyd Common, north of Pontardawe To view look up responderID 1469 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Association of Electricity Producers New ovrhead lines reqd is welcomed. Assumptons on economics of develpment best left to developer. Disappointed that Tactical Training Areas are excluded. To view look up responderID 1380 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 Anne and Andrew George * To view look up responderID 601 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8WithSiteExceptions Amgen (Dafydd Huws) Argues that methodology of TAN8 designations is flawed. There are many suitable places outside the SSAs (including Camddwr - and East Anglia), and some unsuitable places within the SSAs (including m To view look up responderID 112 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Amegni Developers need reassurance from Assembly Government that required grid in Mid and North Wales can be delivered to support wind energy To view look up responderID 705 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
NonGovOrg AgainstTan8 All Wales Energy Group, Llanfynydd Includes a paper on extent of reduction in CO2 emissions from wind power To view look up responderID L64 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
NonGovOrg NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 All Wales Energy Group Detailed presentation .Presents an alternative scenario of installing 1.5kw wind turbines to individaul homes resulting in greater carbon savings Includes a paper/publication Wind Year 2003 To view look up responderID L9 in file:
lateResponses.pdf(18 mb)
CompanyEnergy NeutralTendingForTan8 Alkane biogas Ltd * To view look up responderID 717 in file:
700-799.pdf(7 mb)
CompanyEnergy ForTan8 Albro Planning & Environmental and Dulas Ltd In section 33 they argue that Nant y Moch is a "curious inclusion" because of the "nationally acclaimed" Plynlymon range", hydrological patterns and lack of roads. To view look up responderID 1461 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 Alan & Tess Townsend Regular visitors from Guildford To view look up responderID 604 in file:
600-699.pdf(8 mb)
OtherGovOrg NeutralTan8 Planning Inspectorate john.davies@pins.gsi.gov. Whole Tan 8 with manuscript comments, difficult to read. To view look up responderID 595 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual ForTan8 individual wind farm developer Climate change knows no borders so why should efforts to reverse the change be hampered by lines on a map. To view look up responderID 1270 in file:
1200-1299.pdf(6 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * From Sherborne, Dorset, visitor To view look up responderID 1136 in file:
1100-1199.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Succinct case. "Poor Wales. It suffered through coal exploitation.....allowed valleys to be drowned... beautiful ancient monuments to be devastated... now allowing wild and beautiful countryside To view look up responderID 1365 in file:
1300-1399.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Says when he voted for a National Assembly he did not realise he was voting to destroy the Welsh countryside. A very detailed response. To view look up responderID 838 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * draft documents give an impression of arrogance on the part of the WAG in its determination to force local authorities to approve installation irrespective of local opinion. To view look up responderID 1043 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * against strategicv area C but thinks there are other options as altlernatives to tan8 To view look up responderID 1047 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * "turbinisation of valued landscapes" To view look up responderID 1048 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Rhos Cilybebyll, Alltwen, Pontardaw, Clydach. I can't believe that the Welsh Assembly would behave in such an insensitive manner To view look up responderID 1050 in file:
1000-1099.pdf(26 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Landowner and upland sheep farmer To view look up responderID 879 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Plea from a youth leader To view look up responderID 892 in file:
800-899.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * "Please, please save our lovely land and seascapes." To view look up responderID 948 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * The need for wilderness vis a vis carbon reduction through wind turbines To view look up responderID 949 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * # should perhaps fall into a 'buisiness other' categoroy' To view look up responderID 918 in file:
900-999.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * More or less illegible so I have guessed To view look up responderID 1495 in file:
1400-1499.pdf(13 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * One of the few cases where the responder is against one particular area- Llanllwni but not against other areas. To view look up responderID 1511 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * #makes the point made by many that there has been insufficient publicity concerning the draft. To view look up responderID 1543 in file:
1500-1599.pdf(10 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Not against wind turbines per se - suggest they build them in the Home Counties To view look up responderID 211 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual NeutralTan8 * Not against wind farms generally - but wants no more in Wales To view look up responderID 232 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * In favour of small scale domestic wind power To view look up responderID 314 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Against tan8 generally but specifically mentions Mynydd y Gwair To view look up responderID 261 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Aged 11 and 10 To view look up responderID 263 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 * Comments are general about wasteful and useless developements - traffic etc- and other options for power. No specific mention of Tan8/windmills To view look up responderID 264 in file:
200-299.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * A farming f amily view To view look up responderID 113 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Another view from a farmer To view look up responderID 120 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * A view from a farm address To view look up responderID 134 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * "Without prejudice to 'Rape of the Fair Country'............ May God forgive your shortsightedness" To view look up responderID 12 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingForTan8 * Thoughtful letter To view look up responderID 14 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Another thoughtful letter To view look up responderID 81 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
LocalGovernment AgainstTan8 * Well-argued letter from Denbighshire County Councillor. (Asks why Landmap wasn't used.) To view look up responderID 82 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Objecting to the Glyncorrwg proposals. Says the village has become beautiful since the slag heaps have gone and turbines would ruin their landscape To view look up responderID 545 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual ForTan8 * "public should not have a say" To view look up responderID 1 in file:
1-99.pdf(7 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Thoughtful letter To view look up responderID 151 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * From Penrhyncoch To view look up responderID 154 in file:
100-199.pdf(5 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Well argued case To view look up responderID 567 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
NotAnalysed NotAnalysed * Relates to the proposed Camddwr development To view look up responderID 568 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Against SSA area G specifically Regular English tourists To view look up responderID 569 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Specifically against offshore turbines with no mention of land based turbines. To view look up responderID 588 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Specifically against wind, not other forms of alternative energy To view look up responderID 589 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Objector 12 years old. To view look up responderID 563 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Uses SSA area A for much of objection. Why was Tan 8 document not bi-lingual? To view look up responderID 565 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * 577,578 and 570 accepted by Welsh Govt. as three responses though just one letter signed by three individuals. To view look up responderID 579 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Specifically Mynydd y Gwair, Swansea but does suggest all other rural areas also need protection. To view look up responderID 524 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * From Oxfordshire. To view look up responderID 483 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 * Should also consider wave and tidal as part of the mix. To view look up responderID 489 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual ForTan8 * To view look up responderID 515 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * inappropriate that measures to remove the blight of coal mining are having a beneficial effect that the same areas should be subjected to a new form of industrial pollution. To view look up responderID 521 in file:
500-599.pdf(12 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Objector aged 8. To view look up responderID 440 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * To view look up responderID 442 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Specifically SSA area A (Denbigh Moors) and lack of Assembly cosultation To view look up responderID 444 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual NeutralTendingAgainstTan8 * Emphasises marine sources. To view look up responderID 447 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * "When will it be acknowledged that wind power is just a silly dream hindering serious debate and planning about electricity supply in future years" To view look up responderID 464 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Damage to tourism and quality of life will far outweigh the percieved advantages To view look up responderID 357 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * There is a limit to what the public should put up with. Another responder saying that the scars of industry have been rehabilitated in South Wales and for our grandchildren's sake it should not be rev To view look up responderID 375 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual NeutralTan8 * Makes reccomendations to improve the draft tan8 document with rewording suggested To view look up responderID 376 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * 4 signatories. To view look up responderID 411 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstTan8 * Against in general but with Brechfa Forest specified. Quite nicely penned. To view look up responderID 435 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * The Glyncorrwg area has developed from a 'depressed area' to avery forward thinging and possible tourist area. Munch needed money has been put into the aea by WAG and local council. This will all be a To view look up responderID 386 in file:
300-399.pdf(9 mb)
Individual AgainstOne+Tan8 * Specifically Swansea to Brecon Beacons area. The Valley has only just been .... from the hands of th emine and steel barons. Now you want to invaded the natural beauty once again. To view look up responderID 402 in file:
400-499.pdf(9 mb)
Whilst all the responses were exaned and classified the analysts chose to comment on some responses. The comments made are listed above as are the associated responder names. You may see the original response by clicking on the file name in the extreme right hand column after noting the identification number of the submission. This will download a file of approximately 100 responses which will contain the response you have selected. Some of the files are quite large and will take a while to download. Save the downloaded (pdf) file somewhere on your computer so that you can refer to it without further downloading should you wish to examine any further responses contained in the file.

Entries are in reverse alphabetical order of the responder's name

Use your browser's usual 'Find' facility if you wish to search for a phrase on this page.
Return to menu page
 
rolex replica sale, replica watches uk, hublot replica sale, rolex replica sale